Which Boots are Best?

I have a problem.  It's not a life or death situation, no nothing like that... it's not a serious problem at all, it's silly really, but I wouldn't mind your help.  I've always been a little indecisive.  I'm working on it and I'd like to say that I'm better than I was (Kyle may disagree) but buying clothes is one of my worst areas.  I let things sit in my closet with the tags still on while I'm "deciding" if it's something I really want or not.  It's sad but true.  Case in point; I got a pair of jeans last August at the Nordstrom sale and they sat in my drawer with the tags on for six months.  Recently when I got some boots (back to these in a minute) I remembered them and pulled them out to try on with the boots.  They were perfect with boots, I LOVED them!  Yay! I thought,  I'm keeping these for sure, I can finally take the tags off.  Then I squatted down to the floor to change Lizzy's diaper and RIIIIPP the knee split wide open... I took them back. :(

So, all this brings me to the problem at hand, Boots.  I've been looking for cute riding style boots for a while now, and I finally found not one pair I like, but three!  Which leaves me with a decision to make.  Which boots are best?  I need to make it soon, I need to send the other two pairs back cause I can't keep them all people.  I'm desperate.  So, I've decided to take a poll.  Take a look see below and cast your vote!  Which boots do YOU think are best?

Boots #1

bonus: these are from REI so I could return them forever :)

Boots #2

Boots #3

these are the tallest and the biggest in the calf- I have small calves

OK folks, there they are.  A quick note: all 3 pairs are very comfortable, they were all a great deal, and I want to wear them with skinny jeans or dresses.  Vote below for #1, #2, or #3!  Thanks everybody!

#1                                                                                #2                                                                     #3